Info EDUARD
Synced!
Request for consent to store optional information

We do not need to store any information (cookies, etc.) for the basic functioning of the website. However, we would like to ask for your consent to store optional information:

Anonymous Unique ID

Thanks to it, next time we will know that it is the same device and we will be able to more accurately evaluate the traffic. This identifier is completely anonymous.

Aa

Aa

Aa

Aa

Aa

 

 

 

 

aA

“The Story”

Title photo: My Baby, B-17G-35-DL while her original assignment with the 324th BS, prior the 91st Bomb Group red-tail marking was applied. [NARA]


Somewhere in England, August 10, 1944 

 

I was probably five or six years old when I first heard “The Story” and looked at those three tiny 2 1/2” X 4” photos of the B-17.  This story and those small images were probably responsible for my life long love affair with aviation history. 

 

My Dad, then Captain Edward Mautner, had arrived in England on July 9, 1944, attached to the 127th Station Hospital based in Salisbury in the south of England.  Salisbury was one of the four whole blood distribution centers for the European Theatre of Operations (ETO) and in particular for the troops breaking out from the Normandy beachhead.  My dad was charged with developing a transportation unit to deliver whole blood to field hospitals supporting the troops advancing into France.

Captain Mautner’s first challenge was to find vehicles – two and half ton trucks (“deuce and halfs”), Jeeps, motorcycles, trailers, and refrigeration units to extend the short shelf life of whole blood.  He also had to create a cadre of drivers.  The 127th arrived with only 11 licensed drivers and two men qualified to ride motorcycles- Corporal T/5 Lyle Holcomb and my dad.  All the vehicles were requisitioned without paperwork, including 20 Harley-Davidson motorcycles. Training began on the Salisbury Plain.  Teaching young men to drive trucks and Jeeps was pretty easy.  The motorcycles were not quite so easy to master.  Men were taught to start, accelerate, brake and shift gears.  They were then sent out on the grassy plain and told to practice and return in one half hour.  Several did not return having dumped their motorcycles and found them too heavy to right.  A search party led by Captain Mautner and a few semi-competent novices then rode out in search of the lost sheep.  Once found, they were sent out again.

“Airbase somewhere in England, 10 Aug. 44. “Mac” standing beneath the nose of his plane. I am under the inboard port motor but it was rather dark and the picture isn’t too clear”.  [Mautner]


The point in mentioning this is to emphasize the acute shortage of vehicles and drivers. “Midnight requisitions,” a kind term for thievery, by other needy units depleted others of their hard-won caches of vehicles and made securing vehicles of paramount importance.  And so it was on the afternoon of August 10, 1944 when Lt Y.Z. Garner of Birmingham, Ala., entered Capt. Mautner’s office seeking a favor. Garner wanted to borrow Mautner’s Jeep.  One of his best buddies from Birmingham, an Eighth Air Force B-17 pilot, was flying into a nearby U.S. Army Air base and Garner wanted to drive to meet him.  Mautner, concerned for the security of “his” Jeep, offered to accompany Garner to that base which was approximately 15 miles southeast of Salisbury.

Stoney Cross was a Ninth Air Force base in the New Forest about 10 miles west of Southampton. This former RAF base was home to P-38s of the 376th Fighter Group that had recently flown off to newly bulldozed fields near the Normandy beaches.  Remaining at Stoney Cross were the Martin B-26 Marauder Medium Bombers of the 387th Bombardment Group.  The seemingly short ride to Stoney Cross over narrow, hedge cropped roads took over an hour.  Arriving in mid to late afternoon, Mautner and Garner quickly identified a lone B-17 Flying Fortress that dwarfed a field of B-26 medium bombers.

Finding the crew of the B-17 proved a little more challenging.  Questioning base Army Air Force personnel led Mautner and Garner to the base Officers’ Club or “O Club.”  Garner’s friend was at the bar with a co-pilot. Both had been drinking.  After salutations and introductions, Garner’s friend, introduced as “Mac,” asked his guests if they would like a ride in “his” airplane.  He didn’t have to wait long for a pair of affirmatives.  The only hold up was how to get the co-pilot back into the aircraft as he was quite inebriated and needed assistance.  Once hoisted into the aircraft, he was unceremoniously laid on the plywood floor of the radio operator’s compartment, unable to sit upright in his right front seat.  This is where he remained as “Mac” took the controls, Garner sat in the co-pilot’s seat and Mautner stood between the two with no more than a good grip on their seat backs.  Mautner recalled that they seemed to use all of the 5000 foot runway to get airborne.

“Somewhere in England, 10 Aug 44. “Mac” and I just after we landed. It was almost dark when we came in. Had a grand flight. These “Forts” are the greatest bombers in the world”. War time censorship prevented CAPT Mautner from noting that he was at Station 452, Stoney Cross, in the New Forest. [Mautner]

 

“Mac” asked his guests what they would like to see on their “joy ride.”  Like so many American servicemen in England, the White Cliffs of Dover on the Channel Coast was a familiar landmark made famous by English wartime singer Vera Lynn’s song of the same name.  Told that they had no clearance to fly anywhere near the coast for fear of being shot at by shore batteries, Mautner suggested a flight over their base in Salisbury.  The flyover turned out to be an epic “buzz job” that reportedly left the base volleyball nets in turmoil for several minutes after the event.

The return to Stoney Cross was so late that a caption on the back of one photo noted “...it was almost dark when we came in”.  Mautner took three photos to commemorate the event - one of “Mac” barely visible under the nose of his B-17, one of “Mac” and Garner and a third, taken presumably by Garner, of “Mac” and Mautner. These images are closer in shots that show the aircraft’s nose art and her name – “My Baby.”  Wartime censorship only permitted my father to caption the images “Somewhere in England, 10 Aug. 44,” and finally that these “…’Forts’ are the greatest bombers in the world.”  They watched “Mac” take off for his home base and returned to their base in Salisbury. Upon their return, base personnel excitedly describing the whipping volleyball nets.

Mautner recounted that about a month later Lt Garner came to him in tears.  He had just been notified that his good friend “Mac” had been shot down and killed on a mission over Germany. And so ended Dad’s war story - or so I thought.

In the summer of 1994 I was living in Southern California and close to completing a  Master’s Degree in Historic Preservation/Public History.  The subject of my thesis was Aircraft Preservation at the National Air and Space Museum.  For my final research I had arranged an internship at the National Air and Space Museum’s (NASM) Paul E. Garber Preservation, Restoration, and Storage Facility at Silver Hill, Md. for August and September of that year.  I spent those days in Building 10, the preservation/restoration shop, and my late afternoons and evenings researching in the Archives.

My parents were living at the New Jersey Shore.  On Labor Day weekend, 1994, I drove up to visit them.  With my tales of interning at the NASM, my Dad once again related “The Story” and brought out those three tiny photos, which he then bequeathed to my care.  Having spent much of my adulthood reading WW-II aviation history and building model aircraft, these tiny photos now showed so much more to me than they did as a young boy.  Exactly 50 years after my Dad’s joy ride, I had in my hands all of the incentive to find, in Paul Harvey’s words, “The Rest of the Story.”

Note B-26 Medium Bombers of the 387th Bomb Group in the background

 

An Unplanned Research Project

First, it was clear even in these small, low-definition images that the B-17 was not camouflaged, but silver or in Natural Metal Finish (NMF). In the long shot the top of the vertical stabilizer appeared to be a dark color with what appeared to be the top of the letter A in a triangle that was darker than the stabilizer.  In this image much of the aft fuselage was masked by the left wing. But, aft of the national insignia were the letters LG  D.  The close in image of the left nose showed a long line of bomb mission markings and three mission markings on a second line below that.  And the very seductive young lady painted on the nose next to the name “My Baby” painted on a decorative background.   Now I had two research projects to work on at the NASM.

I had already become a bother to the very patient, knowledgeable, and enthusiastic NASM Archives staff in researching my thesis.  They nonetheless guided me to every source in my search for information on “My Baby.”  Roger A. Freeman’s The Mighty Eighth was my first reference.  The large letter A in a black triangle painted on a red vertical stabilizer was the Group identifier for the 91st Bomb Group (BG) stationed at Bassingbourn in Cambridgeshire in the English Midlands.  The letters on the side of the fuselage identified the aircraft as belonging to the 322nd Bomb Squadron (BS).  So, one might ask, what was a B-17 from the 91st BG stationed in the English Midlands doing flying in and out of a 9th Air Force base in the very south of England on August 10, 1944?  Wasn’t there a war on and didn’t “Mac” and his B-17 have bigger fish to fry?

Two Natural Metal Finish (NMF) B-17Gs of the 324th BS. On the left is “Lorraine”, Serial No. 44-8651. In the background is “Mah Ideel”, Serial No. 43-37993, DF-N for Nan. Note the Olive Drab replacement rudder. “Mah Ideel” flew the mission to Ludwigshafen on September 8, 1944. Both aircraft survived the war. [Evers via Kelley]


With the information I now had, NASM Archives staff advised me that they had in their records, and very conveniently in their Reading Room, files of all of the Eighth Air Force Nose Art and names sorted by BG (this collection is now in the files of the National Archives in College Park, Md.).  It took me five minutes to find a small proof image of “My Baby” in the 91st BG file.  The image is an official 91st BG photo of the aircraft and its crew.  Two things jumped out at me. One of the nine crewmen pictured was the same “Mac” in my father’s small photos. And the official photo showed the same number of bomb mission markings as those shown in my dad’s photos.  Could this photo have been taken on the same day that “My Baby” flew down to southern England to offer two Army officers a “joy ride” around the English countryside?  I ordered an 8” X 10” copy of this photo.

“Yankee Belle,” a B-17G, Ser. No. 42-32085, DF-K from the 324th BS that was also on the same mission to Ludwigshafen, September 8, 1944, the day David McCarty was lost in “Roxy’s Special.” “Yankee Belle” displays the same Natural Metal Finish (NMF) and Group markings as both “My Baby” and “Roxy’s Special.” 


Roger A. Freeman, an Englishman famous for his documenting of all things Eighth Air Force in WW-II, also wrote The Mighty Eighth War Diary. It has more photos and anecdotal stories of the men, aircraft, and missions of the Eighth.  It is also an operational diary, a day by day record, of the missions and activities of the Eighth Air Force. It is an education in the organization of the Eighth.  The primary unit of any BG is the squadron consisting of 12 aircraft.  Normally, a BG has four squadrons.  Above the Eighth’s BGs were three Air Divisions, each consisting of 16 to 18 BGs.  The 91st BG was a part of the First Air Division.  Turning to Freeman’s War Diary and searching for August 10, 1944, one discovers that the First Air Division stood down on this date – no mission was assigned to the 91st.  So “Mac” and “My Baby” had a day off.  How “Mac” got to fly a B-17 from Bassingbourn to Stoney Cross can only be guessed.  This may have been an opportunity to break in or “zero time” a new engine, but clearly “Mac” had another mission on his mind – to visit his buddy,  Lt Y.Z. Garner, based in Salisbury.

Another image of “Mah Ideel,” DF-N for Nan. 


Finding “Mac”: An Amateur Sleuth Goes to Work

In September, 1994 I found a new resource that proved key to unlocking the mystery of who “Mac” was and how he was lost over Germany. Again, following the suggestions of the NASM Archive’s staff, I found another English author who focused on the 91st BG.  Ray Bowden’s book Plane Names and Fancy Dames is a treasure trove of 91st BG aircraft names, nose art, and history of each of the aircraft that Bowden has been able to get images of and information on.  The artwork and name on “My Baby” was painted by T/Sgt. Anthony L. “Tony” Starcer, “…destined to be one of the most prolific and skilled nose art painters in the entire USAAF.”   Starcer painted most of the best known aircraft in the 91st BG including the “Memphis Belle,” “Chow Hound,” “Man O War,” and “Shoo, Shoo, Shoo Baby.”  The figure on the left nose of “My Baby” was modeled on a photo of Brazilian dancer and Hollywood movie star, Carmen Miranda. A single color image shows lettering for “My Baby” was red with a black shadow on a white field with a yellow decorative frame.

“My Baby” photographed in early or mid-summer, 1944. Photo shows 43 mission markings. She would be shot down by fighters on September 5, 1944 on her 58th mission.


Bowden’s write-up on “My Baby” contains a great deal of information and dispelled several preconceptions I had.  She was a B-17G, distinguished from earlier models by a chin turret.  Her serial number was 42-107033.  She was shot down by fighters on September 5, 1944, on a mission to the I.G. Farben Chemical Works in Ludwigshafen, Germany.  It was her 58th mission, but only the second mission for her young pilot, Lt Ernest Robert “Bob” Kelley, who survived the shoot down.  Seventeen different pilots and crews had flown her. My first preconception, that a pilot and crew were assigned an aircraft and stayed with that aircraft until they had met the required mission total and returned to the States, proved incorrect..  Of the pilots mentioned in Bowden’s history, none had Irish or Scottish last names that began with Mc or Mac.  But the September Fail To Return (FTR) date matches my Dad’s “one month” later time frame, I thought that perhaps Lt. Kelley’s nickname might be “Mac” and he had not been killed after all. But how to find out was my next challenge.  Ray Bowden quoted Kelley several times in his notes, so I wrote to Bowden to find out if Kelley was alive and if so, how to contact him.

Bowden was happy to get the information on my dad’s “joy ride’ in “My Baby” and graciously gave me his contact information for Ernest “Bob” Kelley which indicated that he lived in northern California.  My call that was picked up by “Bob” Kelley who was surprised, but very pleased that someone was calling him about his mission in “My Baby.” He gave me much information while trying to recall names fifty years in his past.  Soon he recalled that “Mac” was Lt David McCarty Jr., who was in the same 322nd BS that Kelley was in.  Kelley also recalled that McCarty was lost on another mission over Germany, but had no further details.   But he provided a wealth of information about his second and last and “My Baby’s” 58th and last mission.

An official USAAF photo of “My Baby” with McCarty and crew. Mission markings, a day off for the 1st Bomb Division, and transfer to “Texas Chubby, the J-ville Jolter” on August 11, indicate that this photo was taken at Bassingbourn on the morning of August 10, 1944. Back row, L-R: 1Lt David McCarty Jr., Pilot; 2Lt James McElroy, Co-Pilot; 2Lt Ernest Austin, Navigator; 2Lt Frank Bolen, Bombardier; and Sgt. George Hawes, Radio Operator. Front row L-R: Cecil Seeking, Ball Turret; Harold Beeman, Waist Gunner; Floyd “Tex” Dillon, Tail Gunner; T/Sgt. David Wolnowitz, Top Turret. Of those shown only McCarty, Dillon, and Bolen were on “Roxy’s Special” when she was shot down on September 8, 1944. Of these only Bolen survived to become a POW.

Image of Tony Starcer’s artwork on “My Baby”. The colors indicated conform to Bob Kelley’s recollection.

Small piece of “My Baby “ recovered from her crash-site years after her dismiss.

“Roxy’s Special”, B-17G , Serial No. 43-38348, LG-O, 322nd BS, lost with 1Lt David McCarty Jr. and his crew over Ludwigshafen on September 8, 1944. This was the only loss in the 322nd BS that day. Arriving at Bassingbourn on August 18, 1944, she was lost only three weeks later on her 5th mission. Officers pictured are the crew of Capt. Suther. 

“Texas Chubby, The J-ville Jolter”, B-17G, Serial No. 42-31634, LG-O, 322nd BS. First flown by Texan, Lt Ray R. Ward who named this Olive Drab over Neutral Gray aircraft. Photo shows the Ward crew in front of a freshly arrived and mission free aircraft. 

With over 40 mission markings, “Texas Chubby” looks a bit second hand in this image. McCarty and crew flew her on August 11, 13, 14, and 15, 1944. She was lost to fighters over Halle the very next day. Four survived the shoot down with five KIA including her pilot. Crew members shown in this image are unknown to the author. 


“My Baby”: Failure to Return from Mission to Ludwigshafen, Germany, Sept. 5, 1944

Ernest Robert Kelley joined the U.S. Army Air Corps in April, 1943 and was commissioned a 2Lt. in January of 1944 at Stockton Field, Calif.  He did final training at Hobbs, N.M., where he was assigned to be first pilot in B-17s.  Sent next to Rapid City, N.D., he was given a crew of eight with whom he flew to England in July, 1944, the same month my Dad arrived in England. Many crews at this point in the war were sent to England in factory fresh aircraft, which they delivered to depots from which they were assigned to Bomb Groups in need of replacements.  Kelley and crew felt very lucky to be assigned to the 91st BG at Bassingbourn.  Close to Cambridge and known as the “Country Club”, this former RAF base had amenities that attracted politicians, entertainers, and journalists.

Kelley and crew were assigned to the 322nd BS. After he flew familiarization flights around England, Kelley flew his first mission as a co-pilot on September 3, 1944. The target was the submarine pens at Kiel, Germany.  Thirty six aircraft went on the mission and all 36 returned.  Two days later Kelley and his crew were assigned a   mission to bomb the I.G. Farben Chemical Works (today’s BASF at the same location) at Ludwigshafen in western Germany.  The aircraft they were assigned to fly was B-17G, serial Number 42-107033.  This aircraft, initially attached to the 324th BS, had survived 57 missions.

“Roxy’s Special’s” center fuselage lies on Luther Strasse in the city of Ludwigshafen on September 8, 1944. Martin Luther Church is on the left. Richard Braun, a teenager, recalled coming out of the church upon hearing the crash. He noted seeing bodies still strapped to seats and hanging in nearby trees.  [Stadtarchiv, Ludwigshafen]


The 322nd was the second from last and therefore the High Squadron on this mission. Their location in the BG was called “Coffin Corner” and “My Baby” was the 37th and last aircraft, “Tail End Charlie.”  If that wasn’t inauspicious enough, foul weather and a V-1 attack on the airfield that morning heightened anxiety amongst the crew. “My Baby” carried 4400 pounds of incendiary bomb sticks that morning. But Murphy wasn’t through with Kelley and crew.  As the last aircraft to take off, “My Baby” was rocked by prop wash and, barely airborne, she veered slightly to the right and hit an airfield landing light, blowing out a main gear tire.  Assembling at 8000’, they climbed to 21,000’ over France where they encountered worsening weather and the loss of the number three engine.  Heavy flak over Metz, France took out the number four engine.  With loss of all power on the right side “My Baby” was unable to climb and, lagging behind the Group, was advised by the Group Leader to turn back and seek a landing place in France. A return to England was out of the question.

Shortly after turning back, “My Baby” was beset by Luftwaffe Me 109 fighters.  One made a stern run that instantly killed Tail Gunner, S/Sgt. Richard Doyle, and destroyed part of the rudder and elevator. Further rounds damaged the right wing near the dead number three engine. Losing control and altitude rapidly and unable to see through thick overcast, Kelly rang the klaxon advising all to bail out.  Last to leave the doomed B-17, Kelley put on the last parachute hanging in the cockpit and jumped.  Below 5000 feet, he pulled the rip chord and was immediately alarmed by its refusal to spill the chute, forcing him to pull the pilot chute out of its bag.  As “My Baby” flew on, he saw the severe damage to the tail section and noted that an Me 109 continued to pursue the B-17.  A second Me 109 turned toward Kelley and began to fire in his direction putting several holes in his chute.  Clouds and low altitude ended this attack and Kelley soon found himself on the ground in a dense wooded area.  In the meantime, “My Baby” had made a 180 degree, descending turn and, missing the taller buildings of a small town, crashed onto a farmer’s field.  The crash ignited fuel, oil, and the incendiary bomb load creating a huge fire that would continue to burn throughout the night and into the next morning.

A close-up of the Wreckage of “Roxy’s Special’s” center fuselage. 


Kelley could hear a dog barking nearby and the voices of an elderly man and woman.  Understanding French, Kelley realized they were looking for survivors of the bailout.  Making himself known to them he was quickly taken to the local chief of the French Underground and hidden in a deep hole obviously prepared as a fortress/hide out along with his co-pilot, 2Lt Andy Anderson, Navigator, 2Lt Alton Karoli and Bombardier, 2Lt George Lancaster. This hide out was 20 feet deep and contained two rooms partitioned by a large curtain.  One room was the sleeping area and the second room contained rifles, uniforms, and other supplies used to get allied personnel back to their lines. Kelley and Lancaster suffered minor injuries from their bail-outs.  Engineer, T/Sgt. Ira Krammes suffered ligament damage and, unable to walk or run, was captured.  Waist Gunner Sgt. Zalma Michell and Ball Turret Gunner, S/Sgt. Edward Duemmer landed and were assisted by local residents, eventually evading back to the Allied lines.  Radio Operator, T/Sgt. Grover Nordman was found by locals, given a bicycle with which he rode over 50 miles through German-held territory and across Allied lines. The body of Tail gunner S/Sgt. Doyle was found near the wreckage of the aircraft and buried in the local cemetery by the town mayor and two young brothers.  

Kelley, Anderson, Lancaster, and Karoli, after nine days hiding with the French Underground, were picked up by two GI’s who had  wandered near their area in a Jeep.  They still had to meander through the French countryside to avoid pockets of German soldiers in retreat.  Arriving in Paris 12 days after its liberation, Kelley and crew, aware that surviving crews were to report to the USAAF headquarters as soon as they arrived, enjoyed the city’s sights and entertainment for two days before reporting in.  Upon the crew’s return to Bassingbourn on September 17, a large, base-wide party was thrown in the 324th BS hangar.

The wreckage of “Roxy’s Special” lies on Luther Strasse while the remaining pieces fell over an area of several square miles. 


Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower issued orders early in the war that evaders were not to be returned to flying status in the ETO.  This was to protect the French Underground from being compromised in the event a previous evader was captured and tortured.  While there were exceptions to this mandate, Lt Kelly and his crew were flown back to the United States to be trained for action in the Pacific Theatre of Operations.  While Bob Kelley did train in Douglas A-26 Medium Bombers to be flown against Japan, the war ended before he was ordered back into combat                             

 The four evaders return to Bassingbourn 12 days after being shot down in “My Baby.” L-R: Lt Andrew “Andy” Anderson, Co-Pilot; Lt George Lancaster Jr., Bombardier; Lt Alton Karoli, Navigator; and Lt Ernest Robert “Bob” Kelley, Pilot. Anderson, who was the pilot of “Madame Shoo Shoo,” was loaned to the inexperienced Kelley crew for the mission on September 5, 1944.


1Lt David McCarty: Killed in Action on a Mission to Ludwigshafen, Germany, Sept. 8, 1944

Thanks to Bob Kelley, I now knew who “Mac” was.  I wrote again to Bowden who responded with a great deal of information about David McCarty and his loss over Germany.  Bowden also provided a partial list of McCarty’s mission history in the 322nd BS. This provided further evidence that the crew photo and flight to Stoney Cross both took place on August 10, 1944. McCarty and crew first flew “My Baby” on August 8 and then again on the 9th and then flew “Texas Chubby, The J-Ville Jolter,” an olive drab over gray camouflaged B-17G, on August 11,13, 14, and 15. “Texas Chubby” was shot down the following day with another crew on board. Further evidence was provided by 2Lt Frank Bolen, bombardier assigned to the crew of “Chow Hound,” another well known, Starcer decorated B-17, in the 322nd BS.  On August 7, 1944, Bolen was relieved of his duties as bombardier by the squadron’s

lead bombardier because “Chow Hound was to lead the entire squadron on a mission in support of the Normandy breakout. "Chow Hound" and all of her crew were lost on that mission. With no time to reflect on the loss of his crew, Bolen was immediately assigned to the McCarty crew and is shown in the official 91st BG photo that now appears to have been taken on the morning of August 10, the same day McCarty flew “My Baby” to Stoney Cross.

The 322nd BS hangar at Bassingbourn taken during the “Big Snow” of December, 1944. This structure is a twin to the 322nd BS hangar used to celebrate the return of “My Baby’s” officers on September 17, 1944.


McCarty and crew’s next mission was on September 8 in an NMF B-17G, serial no. 43-38348 named “Roxy’s Special.” On that day, this aircraft was listed “Missing in Action” (MIA) on only its fifth mission and McCarty listed as “Killed in Action”

(KIA) over the same target that saw the loss of “My Baby” three days earlier – the I.G. Farben Chemical Plant in Ludwigshafen.  And this fit almost perfectly my dad’s recollection of Lt Garner’s announcement of Mac’s loss.

On Friday morning, September 8, 1944, McCarty and crew sat in the “Roxy’s Special” which held twelve 500lb. Demolition Bombs. Shortly after 7:22, as the sun began to rise, McCarty guided the aircraft off the Bassingbourn runway and headed east flying in the “right box” of the Low Group just to the right of the lead squadron.  Climbing above the English Channel to a height of 9000 feet, McCarty headed toward Paris where the entire Group would climb to 26,000 feet.  Time over the target, was to be 11:48 a.m.  Minutes before bomb release, the aircraft was hit by an anti-aircraft round probably from an 88mm. flak cannon.  It hit near the number three engine (the right engine, closest to the cockpit) with devastating results.  The wing was severed at that point and the aircraft was seen to fall burning in a flat spin.  Witnesses saw the B-17 explode in mid-air.  The nose was severed from the rest of the fuselage with both the Bombardier, 2Lt Frank S. Bolen, and Navigator, 1Lt Donald Brazedons trapped by centrifugal force.  Eventually both were spilled out of the nose and parachuted to safety – sort of.  They were the only survivors as the others were either killed instantly or trapped in the aircraft as it spun on fire into the city of Ludwigshafen. “Roxy’s Special” was the only 91st BG loss on that mission.

The I. G. Farben Chemical plant is near the confluence of the Rhine and Neckar Rivers. Brazedons came down just north of the confluence and on the west side of the river, almost on the burning chemical plant property and was capturedimmediately.   Frank Bolen landed north of Brazedon on a tiny island where the Altrhein Canal enters the Rhine at Sandhofen. Bolen was knocked unconscious from the impact and once awake discovered that his right ankle was badly sprained.  Waiting until dark, he found a rowboat that eventually got him to the east bank of the Rhine where, moving north, he eventually reached the west bank at the city of Worms.  Traveling only at night and hobbled by the sprained ankle, he worked his way west for seven days. Forced to begin moving during daylight to protect his ankle, he was captured on September 14th and transferred to Stalag Luft I. for the duration of the war.  Stalag Luft I. was at Barth, on the Baltic Sea and was a temporary home to many Allied airmen.

A photo of the 322nd BS hangar during the preparation of squadron personnel for a group photo. A zoomed-in detail shows the 42-31634 'Texas Chubby' standing in the background. [NARA]


“Roxy”s Special” fell in many pieces onto downtown Ludwigshafen.  The center fuselage/cockpit fell on Luther Strasse directly in front of Luther Church and was actually viewed by a young boy who was at the church that day. Richard Braun, hearing a crash, came out of the church and saw bodies in the aircraft and dangling from nearby trees.

The bodies of 1Lt David McCarty Jr., 2Lt Neil M. Mylin (Co-Pilot),  Sgt. Frank F. Trim Jr. (Ball Turret Gunner), S/Sgt. Charles E. Beebe (Waist Gunner), and S/Sgt. Floyd Z. Dillon (Tail Gunner) were interred in the Ludwigshafen Central Cemetery on September 14, 1944. Top Turret Gunner and Flight Engineer T/Sgt. John Cangemi  was initially listed as (MIA). There is no record of his initial interment, but at some point his body was located after the war and reinterred at a U.S. Military cemetery in Minnesota. T/Sgt. Henry R. Schulz is buried at the New Saint Marcus Cemetery, Affton, Missouri. Frank Trim was originally a Waist Gunner on Bob Kelley’s crew.  During the summer of 1944 the 8th Air Force began to reduce B-17 and B-24 crews from ten to nine. This was done by removing one of the waist gunners in each aircraft and assigning them to other positions with other crews. Trim was lost doing Ball Turret duty on McCarty’s crew on “Roxy’s Special”.

David McCarty was born on his family’s farm in Gardendale, Ala. on February 6, 1922.  David’s parents, David Sr. and Dorothy Ethel Clark, moved to North Birmingham in 1925.  David Sr. became the owner of Northside Lumber Company, Inc.  It was shortly after this move that David’s sister, Ethel Jean was born. David attended grade school in North Birmingham and Philips High School near downtown Birmingham.  Graduating Philips in 1939, David entered the University of Alabama and began studying Pre-Law.  He also took courses at University Center,Birmingham.

Bob Kelley at a July Fourth parade in 2009. He still fits into his 1944 uniform. Bob was 96 years old and healthy as a horse until a stroke took him down. We corresponded until the end.  Yes, we had become friends and met out in California and spent a day together sometime around 2014-2015. 


David’s sister, Jean, said David had inherited his dad’s entrepreneurial skills at an early age, managing a newspaper route for the Birmingham News Age Herald, delivering newspapers on his bicycle and growing his route successfully. Once old enough to drive at 16, he drove a garbage truck for the City of Birmingham in the early hours before school opened.  When this became an interference to school attendance and work he switched to working after school and on weekends at the family lumber yard, eventually becoming Vice President of Northside Lumber Company prior to volunteering for military duty.

 David is remembered by his sister as a young man interested in mechanics and carpentry and an excellent partner to his dad in the management of the family’s lumber business.  He also was very interested in real estate and land development.  She also remembers rides on his motorcycle and, no surprise here, for a “buzz job” of the family home in North Birmingham just prior to his transfer to England.

A desire to fly aircraft and fearing being drafted into the Infantry or Navy, David volunteered for the U.S. Army Air Corps and was sent to Flight School at Maxwell Air

Force Base in Montgomery, Ala.  On March 10,1943 he began Primary Training at Avon Park, FL and, later,  Advanced Training at Gunter Field in Montgomery. When

he graduated from Flight Training at Freeman Field Ind., he received the single gold bar of a 2Lt on December 5, 1943, one month before Bob Kelley was commissioned.   Assigned to bombers, David did further training at Salt Lake City and Dahlbert, Texas, before flying to England where he served with the 91st BG, 322nd BS until his loss on September 8, 1944.

He was very respected by those who flew with him.  Frank Bolen, survivor of David’s last mission said he was “… nice and easy going, but not reserved.” And that he was  “… an excellent and confident …” pilot.  Dave Wolnowitz who was a member of David’s crew prior to that final mission remembers David as “… quiet and the nicest guy in the world …” and “… a great pilot”.

David McCarty Jr. was survived by his parents, sister, Ethel Jean McCarty, and

grandmother, Mrs. Rose Clark McCarty.  The family asked the U.S. Military to return

David’s body to Birmingham where his funeral service and final burial took place in July 1947.  He is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery in Birmingham.

The body of David McCarty Jr. was returned to Alabama by his family in 1947. He is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery in Birmingham. He is survived by his sister Ethel Jean Kittrell.  [Forest Hill Cemetery]

 

Who Would Have Thought Such Tiny Photos Could Lead To So Much Information

I could never have imagined that those three tiny images would lead me to so many sources of information.  Not only was I able to find what happened to “My Baby” and her pilot, David McCarty Jr., but I was able, with the help of so many, to locate people who had had flown “My Baby” and survived McCarty’s last mission.  Archivists and Bob Kelley helped discover photos of McCarty and the B-17’s that he flew. Bob Kelley sent me a piece of “My Baby” that he recovered from a farmer’s field many years after her crash.  My late father was astounded by all of this information and amazed that he was able to hold an actual piece of the B-17 that he had a “joy ride” in on August 10, 1944.

David McCarty was 22 years old when he was shot down over Germany on September 8, 1944. Dad was 26.  Young men united for a carefree afternoon flying over the south of England.  For my dad it was a lifetime memory. For me, it has been an opportunity to honor my Dad’s role in WW II.  But it has also been an opportunity to remember a pilot who did not return to tell his kids amazing tales of his missions with the Mighty Eighth over Nazi Germany.  They were all a part of “The Greatest Generation” and their service should never be forgotten.

 

Acknowledgements

This has been quite a tour and I could not have tied all the loose ends together without those who have generously contributed information, photos, contacts, and editorial assistance.  Bob Kelley very early on got me moving toward solving the puzzle of who was “Mac” and the story of the demise of “My Baby.” He referred me to many contacts that filled voids in “The Story.” He also offered me many photos of “My Baby” and finally, a relic removed from her burned out carcass that lies below a French farmer’s bean field. Bob became not only an advisor, but a good friend who did live to see this story completed. Jean McCarty Kittrell, David McCarty’s sister sent not only the recollections of a teenaged younger sister, but a careful list of editorial corrections. Her career as an English Professor made her eminently qualified to do so.  Old friend and writer, Ken Dalecki, also offered assistance in the editorial process. The Archives staff at the National Air and Space Museum lent their knowledge and enthusiasm.  Brian Nicklas, Melissa Keiser, and Larry Wilson could not have been more helpful in pointing me in the right direction.  My early contact with them in 1994 and my subsequent employment at the NASM have created enduring friendships with them.  Frank Bolen and David Wolnowitz were also very generous with information about David McCarty and his last mission. Ray Bowden and The USAAF Nose Art Research Project were a critical source of information on McCarty and the B-17s that he flew. I am also grateful to the 91st Bomb Group Memorial Association for their assistance and Jan Zdiarsky for his interest in this story that led him to provide additional research, photos, editorial assistance and encouragement. 

11/2023
Info EDUARD 11/2023

Good Day, Dear Friends We find ourselves in the same situation with November’s new releases as we did with the October ones, in that they also have been available for purchase a couple of weeks ahead of the newsletter announcement, meaning that they will already be known to a large percentage of readers and perhaps even in their possession.

11/1/2023

Read

Don't miss out

Editorial

Editorial

Good day, Dear Friends After the February premiere and the March sequel of the P-40E, it's time for what was probably the most significant foe of the Warhawks, the Japanese Zero. The last new release of a member of the Zero family, the Rufe float version, was exactly two years ago, in April 2023.

04/2025

KAMIKAZE TOKKŌTAI

KAMIKAZE TOKKŌTAI

One of the most well-known words from the field of aviation, recognized even by those with no interest in the subject, is kamikaze. It is associated with the predominantly aerial campaign that began in October 1944 and lasted until the end of the war in the Pacific. During this period, hundreds of airmen sacrificed their lives in service of the Japanese Empire.

04/2025

Dekelia Greek Air Force Museum

Dekelia Greek Air Force Museum

The Hellenic Air Force Museum is a relatively young institution, having existed in its current form since 1986. However, it certainly has a lot to build on, as its aviation collections were previously part of the Hellenic War Museum. The museum is organisationally under the Hellenic Air Force (HAF) administration and its mission is not only historical research, collection, preservation and access to exhibits, but also the retrieval, conservation and restoration of artefacts related to Greek aviation history.

04/2025

Aerial War in Ukraine - The First Mirage 2000s Have Arrived

Aerial War in Ukraine - The First Mirage 2000s Have Arrived

The full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine began three years ago, on February 24, 2022. This continuation of the series does not only cover the most recent period from February 1, 2025, to February 28, 2025, but also recaps events from the past year. However, we will start with the most significant updates—developments on the global political scene.

04/2025

Like a Painting on Canvas

Like a Painting on Canvas

Market Garden was the largest Allied airborne operation of World War II, launched on 17 September 1944 in the Netherlands. Its objective was to use paratroopers (the "Market" component) and the rapid advance of ground forces (the "Garden" component) to seize key bridges over rivers and canals, thereby creating a corridor for an attack into Germany. However, the operation ultimately failed due to strong German resistance, poor coordination, and delays in the Allied advance, particularly at Arnhem, where British paratroopers were unable to hold a crucial bridge.

04/2025

Tail End Charlie - Almost an April problem

Tail End Charlie - Almost an April problem

It's not entirely my fault that I’m writing my Tail End Charlie text at the last-minute again. I scheduled my work quite responsibly yesterday, Sunday, two days before the current issue was due out. However, somehow I didn't keep up at the end of the day. Understandably, I could blame my slow work, my tendency to run away from responsibilities, orstimuli that release the right hormones into my brain for the wrong mood, and a thousand other things rooted solely in my nature, irresponsibility, and laziness. But this time it's different my friends.

04/2025

Flying Knights in Australia

Flying Knights in Australia

03/2025

P-40E Warhawk

P-40E Warhawk

The Curtiss P-40 line of fighter aircraft stood out among American fighter types for having remained in front-line operations from the summer of 1941, before the U.S. entered World War II, through the end of the conflict four years later. Only Grumman’s versatile F4F Wildcat naval fighter could match that record.

02/2025

Check out other issues

© 2025 Eduard – Model Accessories, s.r.o.

Mírová 170

435 21 Obrnice

Czech Republic

https://www.eduard.com

support@eduard.com

+420 777 055 500

Article “The Story” waiting for thumbnails …

Sending statistics … done (993 ms)

Rendering “The Story” (324928): (23/23) (8 ms)

No sync content to local

Viewport set: width=device-width, user-scalable=0; scale = 1

No sync content to local

Screen: easyReading

--==[ RUN ]==--

Info EDUARD: theme set to 8895

Device info: input=mouse, webkitPrefix=no, screen=1264x0(1)

Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)

 r85/appLogo-123.png

 r85/pubLogoa-156-cz.png

 i7878/item1065901-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065893-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065891-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065894-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065884-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065883-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065882-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065895-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065896-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065903-small.jpg

 i7878/item1065904-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065897-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065898-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065900-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065878-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065879-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065880-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065885-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065881-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065902-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065886-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065888-small.jpg[p2]

 i7878/item1065889-small.jpg[p2]

 p156/vth421083-1.jpg[p1]

 r85/appLogoa-123.png[p1]

 r85/vth512745-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth512770-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth512760-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth512765-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth512748-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth512759-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth508075-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth500096-0.jpg[p1]

 r85/vth489177-0.jpg[p1]

 p156/vth512637-1.jpg[p1]

 i7878/vth421322-1.jpg

 i7878/vth421335-1.jpg